advertisement

opinion: why canada is so far behind israel?

there is a lot canada can learn from israel, which continues to lead the way in the vaccination race.

opinion: why canada is so behind israel in the vaccination race
israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu speaks and gestures during a joint press statement with the visiting president of cyprus, after their meeting at the prime minister's office in jerusalem on february 14, 2021. (photo by marc israel sellem / pool / afp) (photo by marc israel sellem/pool/afp via getty images)
as the world looks cautiously forward to a way out of the covid-19 pandemic, all eyes are on the vaccines. how much, and when, each country will get what’s needed to restart life as we knew it and begin economic recovery are questions that dominate the daily news.
but one country seems to have it figured out.
despite having one of the highest per capita rates of infection in the world, israel has been leading the world in the number of doses of covid-19 administered. canada in 38th place, well, not so much. and just as there are a number of reasons behind israel’s success — the quality and integration of its national health care system, a military focus on logistics, and a “start-up nation” mentality for innovation — there are also many things that explain canada’s failure. one thing, however, is clear: there is a lot our nation can learn.

vaccination
israel procured fewer doses of vaccine per capita than canada, but because of better negotiations and a robust system to rapidly report outcomes of vaccinations, it received a large early allocation. canada negotiated getting most doses beyond april and thought this timetable was fine. as justin trudeau keeps reminding us — as we suffer from almost no vaccine doses in february — “we are still on track.”

advertisement

advertisement

unfortunately, it’s the wrong track with a misguided timeline.
while canada has vaccinated less than three per cent of the population, israel will vaccinate all willing adults of any age within another six weeks. and, while israel’s prime minister negotiated perfectly with pfizer, our prime minister doesn’t even know how many doses we are getting. his best guess is a shot in the dark, rather than israel’s shot in the arm.

vaccine rollout 
israel rolled out its vaccination program with the military precision you would expect from the vaunted israeli army. priority was defined early and effectively, vaccination notification occurred efficiently, and there were few glitches. in contrast, canada’s rollout has been slow, inefficient and with unclear prioritization. while we have a larger and more challenging geography, even toronto can’t get shots in arms efficiently. we have generals, but lack a battle plan and soldiers. there are so many questions that remain unanswered: how will people will be prioritized, and notified? will they have to log into overloaded and frustratingly inefficient websites as has been the case early on? what about those who aren’t internet savvy? when will pharmacies and private providers know their role so they can prepare?

advertisement

advertisement

vaccine efficacy
pfizer reported a 95 per cent vaccine efficacy based on a phase 3 study comparing infection rates in about 15,000 people treated, versus placebo control subjects. this data was critical for regulatory approval. it was equally essential to know how the vaccine behaves in the real world of mass vaccination. is it as effective as in the initial phase 3 trial?  does it prevent bad outcomes? canada has no idea, given our low vaccination rates. we can only disclose how many people remain at risk with no real timetable for getting it done.

the maccabi healthcare systems is israel’s second largest health maintenance organization (hmo) with 2.5 million members. when it reported the comparative differences in infection rates for 416,900 people who received the two pfizer vaccine doses, only 254 from the vaccinated group became infected, compared to the rates for 778,000 people not yet vaccinated — all within nine days after the second dose and none thereafter. by comparison, 12,944 infections occurred in the unvaccinated group. this demonstrates that the vaccine was effective in the large scale vaccination of a diverse population, with large prevention benefit equal to what was seen in the much smaller approval trials. even more exciting is that of the 254 vaccinated people infected early after the second dose, none died. this truly amazing data came from israel first, informs the world, and for the pfizer vaccine, demonstrates the protective effect of vaccination beyond simply disease prevention — it also prevents severe disease.

advertisement

advertisement

where to produce vaccine 
canada spent large amounts of money too late on facilities that can’t produce the most effective vaccines — indeed any useful vaccines — until late this year. we didn’t adequately support all potential vaccine developers in a timely way, by either substantial funding or cutting red tape. in fact, we often added red tape. israel is too small a country to produce vaccine domestically, it bought marketable vaccine early and focused on novel diagnostics and therapeutics

therapeutics
most countries will still need effective therapeutics to manage disease burden. the disease will not die out completely as people opt not be vaccinated and the disease will linger in poorer countries. so what’s the plan to treat residual covid-19? as we have seen throughout the pandemic, repurposed drugs that reduce viral load early in disease, such as remdesivir, have limited benefit. hydroxychloroquine works minimally if at all. even dexamethasone, however important to manage the immune over-reaction, data showed in the u.k. recovery trial that it only saves one life for every eight on ventilators and one out of 25 lives for those requiring oxygen. clearly, we need better options.

advertisement

advertisement

in canada, our scientists are excellent, yet underfunded and there is still so much we don’t know. a canadian funded study of peginterferon lamda-1 given as a single dose reduced viral load in early disease, but its benefit in reducing disease severity is unknown. the colchicine trial led by the montreal heart institute showed early benefit, but needs more data to prove it can reduce poor outcomes. and the anticoagulation trial co-led by toronto’s university health network, showed significant benefit in reducing complications due to clotting and will likely become standard therapy in hospitalized — but not critically ill — patients. it’s worth mentioning that the two latter trials were started by private donor seed money rather than an innovation incubator, and were later supported by peer reviewed funding, which is in too short supply and often underfunds studies as a result.

the trial landscape in israel looks very different. it has three exciting trials underway: biotech enlivex has trialled allocetra, a drug that calms a hyper-immune overreaction. phase 1 and 2 trials showed patients with severe or critical disease as recovered and discharged by day eight, while two critically ill patients were still on a ventilator at day 28. this is great news, but needs a larger randomized trial to validate the results.

advertisement

advertisement

ichilov hospital in tel aviv reported a phase 1 trial of exo-cd24 enriched exosomes. these agents are responsible for cell communication and help regulate the immune system and hopefully mitigate cytokine storm, the likely cause of most severe disease. thirty patients with moderate or severe disease were treated with inhaled doses of the drug, and remarkably, all but one were discharged in three to five days. while the 30th recovered as well, but took a little longer.
pluristem therapeutics is also conducting a trial of placenta derived cellular therapy. if the exciting preliminary results hold up, these drugs are game changers and will likely work for all variants.

digital health care revolution
israel is famously known as the “start up nation,” having more start ups per capita than any country in the world. one company, diagnostic robotics , developed an ai powered platform to guide patient triage to the emergency room with a prediction model for acuity. during covid-19, its platform was used broadly in israel to help determine likelihood of infection and evaluate the need for going to the er, as well as provide anonymized cellphone tracking of contacts. the technology was good enough to partner with the mayo clinic, as well as the state of california. i personally attempted to connect both the provincial and federal governments with diagnostics robotics, which was offering canada its technology for free, however, both governments declined.

advertisement

advertisement

canada isn’t fine
justin trudeau has told us that all the recent angst about lack of timely vaccination is just “ noise ” and we will be fine. we will be fine when we have an integrated national disease database, adequately fund science, research and innovation and create a business environment that facilitates success. israel, the small country that can, has shown us the way to overcome what canada can’t.

dr. harry rakowski is an academic cardiologist based in toronto.

don’t miss the latest 世界杯决赛2022. subscribe to healthing’s daily newsletter.

comments

postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. we ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. we have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. visit our community guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.