advertisement

opinion: are accidents waiting to happen really accidents?

can we even call them accidents when so many people shake their heads knowingly in response to pedestrian deaths?

an accident waiting to happen.
that’s how residents of pierrefonds-roxboro described the tragic death of a 15-year-old girl killed by an out-of-control car this month. angelica john was just steps from her home and on her way to her school bus stop on lalande blvd. when she was struck only days before the end of classes. she died later in hospital, leaving her grieving family reeling.

the driver first struck a hydro pole, then john , then another vehicle, before coming to a stop on the picturesque residential street on the banks of rivières des prairies. montreal police are investigating the cause of the fatal collision.

locals say the narrow road was notoriously risky , with too many motorists speeding in the 40-kilometre-per-hour zone where pedestrians stroll, cyclists ride their bikes, children play and others come to gaze at the waterfront vistas. some say they’ve requested speed bumps or that lalande be transformed into a one-way street to make it safer for those who live in the neighbourhood. borough mayor jim beis said the city had asked police to step up patrols in the area while it considered various options.

an accident waiting to happen is also how the death of an 8-year-old boy was characterized last summer in st-henri.

advertisement

advertisement

he was fatally hit crossing st-ambroise st. near sir georges-étienne cartier square to meet his parent after day camp. the child stopped at the stop sign and so did the driver. but both moved forward again without seeing each other, with tragic consequences. many in st-henri complained that the busy intersection had long been a problem, with parked cars and pedestrians milling on the sidewalk making it difficult for everyone to see.

it was also called an accident waiting to happen when a woman crossing atwater st. near tupper st in december 2018 was hit by a dump truck turning out of the old montreal children’s hospital, which is now being transformed into condos. nearby residents said they had long feared how little time pedestrians were given to traverse a busy thoroughfare with all kinds of machinery coming and going from the construction site all day.

but are these really accidents waiting to happen if so many people see them coming?
can we even call them accidents when so many shake their heads knowingly in response to such tragedies?

according to vision zero, the traffic safety strategy founded in sweden in 1997 and adopted in montreal in 2016 , the answer is no. under vision zero, any death or serious injury on the roads is “unacceptable” and dangers must be addressed through improved design, education and behavioural changes. while montreal has set about reprogramming crosswalk signals to prolong the priority given to pedestrians, securing school zones, reducing speed limits and widening sidewalks, it still seems like the city too often ends up reacting to calamity rather than proactively saving lives.

advertisement

advertisement

the statistics speak for themselves.
the city’s own data says that a person is killed or seriously injured on montreal’s streets every 41 hours.
pedestrian fatalities surged to 24 in 2019, a record for the decade, eclipsing 2018, when there were 18 deaths, a six-year high.

so dropping back to 18 in 2020 is not very reassuring — especially given montreal was in the throes of a pandemic, where schools were closed, many people were working from home and there was noticeably lighter traffic on the roads.

thus far in 2021, eight pedestrians have died, according to the service de police de la ville de montréal. john was the 7th. a man crossing golf blvd. near des sciences blvd. was killed in anjou on june 22 , a few days later, and  is the most recent death.

the toll includes two women who were run over by garbage trucks backing out of alleys: one, age 26, was killed on april 8 in ville-marie ; and another, age 74, died on may 17 in hochelaga-maisonneuve .

typically, seniors account for more than half of pedestrian deaths each year. but age doesn’t matter for those in the wrong place, at the wrong time.
everyone has a part to play when it comes to road safety. drivers of heavy equipment must be extra cautious given their enormous size. motorists must be aware of their surroundings and driving according to the rules. police have a duty to enforce traffic laws. cities have a responsibility to ensure the streetscape is safe.

advertisement

advertisement

but clearly it was too little, too late, to spare the life of john, who
was walking down the sidewalk, a block from home, on her way to her bus stop.
this may seem like an accident waiting to happen, but it’s more a chronicle of a death foretold.
ahanes@postmedia.com

comments

postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. we ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. we have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. visit our community guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.